Topics Addressed

  1. Estimation of Proportions
  2. Enviromental Sciences

Lead is a substance that can produce significant adverse health effects in people who ingest it at high concentrations. One important environmental source of lead used to be paint; another still is drinking water in communities with old plumbing pipes made in part from lead.

The journal Environmental News reported in April 1975 that "The continuing analysis of lead levels in the drinking water of several Boston communities has verified elevated lead concentrations in the water supplies of Somerville, Brighton, and Beacon Hill." Preliminary results of a study carried out in 1974 found that "20% of the 248 randomly chosen households tested in these communities showed lead levels exceeding the U.S. Public Health Service standard of 50 parts per million." In contrast, in Cambridge, which adds anticorrosives to its water in an attempt to keep the lead from leaching out of the pipes, "only 5% of the 100 randomly sampled households showed lead levels exceeding the standard."

Work out a 95% confidence interval for the difference in the proportions of households in Somerville, Brighton, and Beacon Hill on the one hand and Cambridge on the other that had lead levels exceeding the government standard, and carry out a test of the hypothesis of no difference.

Does this evidence prove that adding anticorrosives to the drinking water decreases lead concentrations in communities with a lot of lead pipe plumbing?

Explain briefly.


George Michailides