Morton and co-authors wished to determine if parents who work
around lead
inadvertently increase the level of lead in their children's
blood. Previous studies
suggested that lead dust is brought home on the parents' clothing
and skin, and can get
into the children's bloodstream when the dust is breathed in
or eaten. Lead accumulates in
the blood, so over time even small amounts can build to dangerous
levels.
Laws have been passed to limit the lead in paint, pipes, and other
objects likely to be
found in the home because even very small particles can poison
a child after prolonged
exposure. If workers do in fact bring lead into the home
this way, then careful hygiene at
the factory (showering, changing clothes and shoes, and shampooing
hair before leaving
work) could prevent the lead from contaminating the home.
Seeking the Evidence
For this case study, you
will determine whether there is sufficient
evidence that the children
of workers in this battery factory have
higher levels of lead in
their blood than children whose parents
do not work around lead.
A difference in lead levels between Exposed and Control groups
does not in itself prove
that the parents' exposure caused the children's elevated lead
levels. Only carefully
controlled experiments can answer such questions definitively.
But a controlled experiment is obviously out of the question here,
for how could we
assign children to their parents? Or force parents into
certain occupations? To make the
most of this less-than-perfect (from an experimental perspective)
situation, special care
must be given to the design of the study.